1. Winona Ryder
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/7e123/7e123c21a9aa0797fe1aeb34859a3758a512bdcf" alt=""
2. Olivia Thirlby
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/352a4/352a40c0ca2b506299d6d00247615ed6b4440c10" alt=""
After crashing through to the popular consciousness in last year's little-film-that-could "Juno", Thirlby followed that performance up with two very good roles that are a little less show-me than I'm sure her agents would've liked. First, as a sensitive teenager in David Gordon Green's "Snow Angels", she manages to defy every teen movie cliche and imbue the intellectual loner as something real and three dimensional. While a majority of Green's family maudit drama is overbearing and morose, the relationship that Thirlby and actor Michael Angarano form is a tender respite from the doom and gloom. Next, in "The Wackness"- a film I personally disliked due to lead actor Josh Peck- Thirlby embodies a free spirited teen who oscillates from horny to stand-offish like the best 'teases'. And that's not a slap against her. Her performance, along with the always respectable Ben Kingsley, is very very good.
3. David Stratharn
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/4922c/4922cdb0550dbcf5764ee0b741698db67af9514e" alt=""
As an alcoholic fighting the urges to notice his wife (Rachel Weiscz) flirting with every other guy in the bar, David Strathairn damn well deserves a supporting actor nom for his performance in Wong Kar Wai's elegant "My Blueberry Nights". Episodic and moody, Strathairn's performance is just one of many in the film as wandering Norah Jones stumbles across the United States in search of... something. Strathairn's embodiment of the alcoholic in one segment is just supremely moving and completely unorthodox.
4. Andrew Garfield
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/56613/566135196981c16be98eb965eb53de31f11b1ca5" alt=""
John Crowley's "Boy A" is a psychological puzzle of a movie, flashing the past in subliminal portions, while at the same time following "Jack" (Andrew Garfield) as he attempts to start his life over and leave the past behind him. More intellectual than emotional, Garfield gives a breathtaking performance that easily reveals how even 'bad' people can try to do good. I look forward to more of his work.
5. Michael Shannon
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/d949d/d949d00ea8f2fb4b234a1a034dbd77a2a8697560" alt=""
In "Shotgun Stories", Jeff Nichols' slow burn Southern Gothic debut, Michael Shannon should gain additional credibility as a character actor in the strongest sense of the word. So good in last year's "Bug", Shannon again takes his steely gaze and puts it to good use as the oldest brother desperately trying to keep a cool head in a family squabble that escalates into shocking violence. At first glance, Shannon feels like a one-note performer, but on second glance there's a lot broiling beneath the surface of his intimidating visage. If you haven't seen "Shotgun Stories", I highly recommend it.
6. Robert Downey Jr.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/67c70/67c70eee01e390bd4da5275b4149ad1885a0cbf1" alt=""
Yea, it's probably a cheat to include him in this list since everything the guy touches lately turns to gold, but his performance in "Tropic Thunder" is so funny and self reflexive, that it deserves mention. This is a supporting performance that is made even funnier when you just watch his reactions and don't listen to his dialogue.
7. Kristen Stewart
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/e23b9/e23b92cecfd17724d6e445fe68313a24cd736c44" alt=""
8. Richard Jenkins
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/666ff/666ff3c4aaa955047158905d22b1b8957ecf44ab" alt=""
My money is on Jenkins for a Best Actor win this year. No performance has been quite as masterful as his embodiment of Walter Vale, the widowed professor who becomes involved in an immigration battle when he finds two strangers renting his New York apartment. Jenkins has been such a strong character actor for so long, that his first major leading role shouldn't be a surprise. Still, "The Visitor" is one helluva film held together by his emphatic performance.
I'm curious.. who did I leave off? Thoughts on your own favs?